Lesley Shelton – Teaching Philosophy
Sample Commentary on Student Writing
For low-stakes writing assignments, like these assignments brainstorming research questions and possible sources, I try to focus on the content and to keep the tone positive. I only address grammar concerns if they obstruct understanding of the ideas. I have included some of the student feedback, which I review to determine if my comments are helpful to the students. Overall, the majority of the student comments I receive are positive, even though I consider myself a “hard grader.” I believe that it is better to try to pull students up to the next level of writing competency than to lower my standards to meet their level of production. Students have a wonderful way of meeting an instructor’s expectations, regardless of how high or how low she sets them; I choose to set my expectations high.
Example 1:
You start with a strong introduction and a pretty good thesis. I'm not so sure about the word "appeasing," but I think that I get your drift.
On the quote from the Austin American Statesman, you still need to give a proper citation, using the title of the article if no author's name is present, something like this:("Financing Public Schools" A2). You should use the section and page number for this source from where the quote is found.
You may want to review the guidelines for using quotes within a quote by using double quotation marks for the outermost quotation marks and single for a quote that is nested within the quoted material. Did Dr. Dotzour write that "School" article, or was he quoted in it?
Your sources are very well chosen. I thought your literature review was well organized and carefully researched. You have done an excellent job and I'm glad I got to read your essay. Thanks for sharing!
On the quote from the Austin American Statesman, you still need to give a proper citation, using the title of the article if no author's name is present, something like this:("Financing Public Schools" A2). You should use the section and page number for this source from where the quote is found.
You may want to review the guidelines for using quotes within a quote by using double quotation marks for the outermost quotation marks and single for a quote that is nested within the quoted material. Did Dr. Dotzour write that "School" article, or was he quoted in it?
Your sources are very well chosen. I thought your literature review was well organized and carefully researched. You have done an excellent job and I'm glad I got to read your essay. Thanks for sharing!
Example 2:
You are wise to narrow your question as you have done. I think that you are on track with your sources for research. Where do you plan on obtaining the statistical data? From government documents? From law enforcement journals? From journals tracking state economics? You did cover some of this ground in your previous assignment. Good for you! You are ahead of the game because you have already begun gathering research. I also agree that the logical organization for your paper is chronological. I think that you have made an excellent start here. Great job.
You are wise to narrow your question as you have done. I think that you are on track with your sources for research. Where do you plan on obtaining the statistical data? From government documents? From law enforcement journals? From journals tracking state economics? You did cover some of this ground in your previous assignment. Good for you! You are ahead of the game because you have already begun gathering research. I also agree that the logical organization for your paper is chronological. I think that you have made an excellent start here. Great job.
Example 3:
I think you have a great start for your paper. Your topic, while it is part of a large (and controversial) subject, is sufficiently narrow if you confine your discussion to the economic impact of minimum wage increases in Texas based on earlier minimum wage increases and recent increases in other states. Based upon your findings, you could then propose whether or not you feel that an increase in the minimum wage would be prudent at this time.
I am sure that you could find ample sources. I doubt if you would have any trouble locating government data on this subject. It is a matter of public record. I also know that on the news a few nights ago they did a piece on states that have recently increased their minimum wage and the impact that it has had on their state economies. I'm sorry, but I don't remember what states.
You may want to use some news magazine (I'm thinking here of something like US News and World Report) sources that contain articles dealing with this subject.
Your ideas are solid and so is your writing. Thanks for sharing your ideas with me.
Student Comment:
This comment was very helpful! I have more ideas and I thank you for them!!
I think you have a great start for your paper. Your topic, while it is part of a large (and controversial) subject, is sufficiently narrow if you confine your discussion to the economic impact of minimum wage increases in Texas based on earlier minimum wage increases and recent increases in other states. Based upon your findings, you could then propose whether or not you feel that an increase in the minimum wage would be prudent at this time.
I am sure that you could find ample sources. I doubt if you would have any trouble locating government data on this subject. It is a matter of public record. I also know that on the news a few nights ago they did a piece on states that have recently increased their minimum wage and the impact that it has had on their state economies. I'm sorry, but I don't remember what states.
You may want to use some news magazine (I'm thinking here of something like US News and World Report) sources that contain articles dealing with this subject.
Your ideas are solid and so is your writing. Thanks for sharing your ideas with me.
Student Comment:
This comment was very helpful! I have more ideas and I thank you for them!!
Example 4:
This topic has been a concern for much longer than the last three years. The mechanization of the assembly line began many years ago. As you have observed, jobs lost to technology continue to be a concern. I think that you have a good topic here, but not necessarily one that "clearly relates to concerns of Texans." I suggest that you ask your instructor if they find this topic acceptable given the parameters of the assignment. Perhaps there is a specific business here in Texas that has been affected by this topic in some significant way. Personally, I like your topic and am interested in seeing what your research turns up.
My first suggestion is to go back further in the history of this subject more than just three years. You will have no trouble in finding material on this subject. The key will be in determining what data to include and what to omit. If you could narrow your focus to a specific business or industry, that would help narrow your research.
Great ideas and solid writing. Thanks for sharing with me!
Student Comment:
Wow! This is one of the few comments that have been VERY helpful to me. The grader thoroughly explained to me and how I can make a good research paper from the question I stated in the assignment. This is how all grader comments should be. Thank you
This topic has been a concern for much longer than the last three years. The mechanization of the assembly line began many years ago. As you have observed, jobs lost to technology continue to be a concern. I think that you have a good topic here, but not necessarily one that "clearly relates to concerns of Texans." I suggest that you ask your instructor if they find this topic acceptable given the parameters of the assignment. Perhaps there is a specific business here in Texas that has been affected by this topic in some significant way. Personally, I like your topic and am interested in seeing what your research turns up.
My first suggestion is to go back further in the history of this subject more than just three years. You will have no trouble in finding material on this subject. The key will be in determining what data to include and what to omit. If you could narrow your focus to a specific business or industry, that would help narrow your research.
Great ideas and solid writing. Thanks for sharing with me!
Student Comment:
Wow! This is one of the few comments that have been VERY helpful to me. The grader thoroughly explained to me and how I can make a good research paper from the question I stated in the assignment. This is how all grader comments should be. Thank you
Example 5:
Okay, you have got me interested! But of what significance is the number of "boxing teams are in the West Texas Association region in Texas"? You are going to have to make your research question more substantial than this. At its most essential, your answer would only be a single number--not much of a paper. But I suspect that you interest in this subject goes way beyond a simple number. Why are you interested in this subject? Of what interest might it be to your peers or other Texans? Are the numbers rising? falling? What does this mean--in your opinion?
You have by far the most unique subject (boxing in Texas) that I have read so far; the problem is that you don't have a thesis. Find a topic and I think that you have a real winner here!
You might want to also include an interview of the president of the West Texas Association, articles from trade journals or sports related newsletters. The key for you here is making certain that these sources meet the requirements of the assignment and that they are reliable and appropriate.
Good luck writing this paper. I hope that I get to read it! If you need help in defining your topic, I suggest going to the writing center or brainstorming your ideas with a friend who shares your interest. I am sure that you can come up with a compelling topic. Just remember that a number is not very interesting unless it means something. What does this number mean to you?
Okay, you have got me interested! But of what significance is the number of "boxing teams are in the West Texas Association region in Texas"? You are going to have to make your research question more substantial than this. At its most essential, your answer would only be a single number--not much of a paper. But I suspect that you interest in this subject goes way beyond a simple number. Why are you interested in this subject? Of what interest might it be to your peers or other Texans? Are the numbers rising? falling? What does this mean--in your opinion?
You have by far the most unique subject (boxing in Texas) that I have read so far; the problem is that you don't have a thesis. Find a topic and I think that you have a real winner here!
You might want to also include an interview of the president of the West Texas Association, articles from trade journals or sports related newsletters. The key for you here is making certain that these sources meet the requirements of the assignment and that they are reliable and appropriate.
Good luck writing this paper. I hope that I get to read it! If you need help in defining your topic, I suggest going to the writing center or brainstorming your ideas with a friend who shares your interest. I am sure that you can come up with a compelling topic. Just remember that a number is not very interesting unless it means something. What does this number mean to you?
No comments:
Post a Comment